Critical theory of justice : On Forst's 'basic structure of justification' from a cognitive-sociological perspective
Part of : Philosophical inquiry ; Vol.39, No.2, 2015, pages 110-133
Issue:
Pages:
110-133
Author:
Abstract:
This article offers a perspective on the critical theory of justice by presenting a structural and processual reconstruction of Rainer Forst's intriguing yet somewhat opaque concept of a basic structure of justification which is central to his proposed critique of justificatory relations. It shows from a cognitive-sociological perspective what a cooperative relation between a philosophical theory of justice and a social scientific approach could mean for critical theory. A basic structure of justification is revealed to be a cognitively available reflexive order above the order of substantive social and political relations that allows the identification, explanation and transformative critique of reflexivity deficits induced by hegemonic, ideological, repressive or obfuscating means. Far from being exclusively a theoretical and methodological tool, however, it is in principle accessible to those involved and affected on whose experience, suffering and critique critical theory vitally depends.
Subject:
Subject (LC):
Keywords:
cognitive sociology, critical theory, critique, discourse, Forst, justification, public
References (1):
- Apel, Karl-Otto(1979) Die Erklären: Verstehen-Kontroverse im transzendentalpragmatischer Sicht. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.Beck, Ulrich (201 l)'We Do Not Live in an Age of Cosmopolitanism but an Age of Cosmopolitisation: The "Global Other"is in Our Midst', Irish Journal of Sociology 19(1): 16-34.Bergman, Mats (2012) 'Pragmatism as a Communication-Theoretical Tradition', European Journal of Pragmatism and American Philosophy 4(1): 208-21.Boltanski, Luc and Thévenot, Laurent (1991) De la Justification: Les Economies de la Grandeur. Paris: Gallimard.Brunkhorst, Hauke (2010) 'Neustart-KritischeTheorie internationaler Beziehungen', Zeitschrift für Internationale Beziehungen 17(2): 293-315.Conein, Bernard(2005) Les Sens Sociaux: Trois Essais de Sociologie Cognitive. Paris: Economica.Craig, Robert T. (2006) 'Pragmatism in the Field of Communication Theory', Communication Theory 17(2): 125-45.Delanty, Gerard (2013) Formations of European Modernity. Basingstoke: Palgrave.Domingues, J. Mauricio (2002) 'Modernity, Complexity and Mixed Articulation', Social Science Information 41(3): 385-406.Eder, Klaus (1996) The Social Construction of Nature. London: Sage.Eder, K. (2007) 'The Public Sphere and European Democracy: Mechanisms of Democratization in the Transnational Situation', in J. E. Fossum and P. Schlesinger (eds) The European Union and the Public Sphere. London: Routledge, pp. 44-64.Forst, Rainer (20l\)Kritik der Rechtfertigungsverhältnisse: Perspektiven einer kritischen Theorie der Politik. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.Gamson, William A. (1988) Ά Constructionist Approach to Mass Media and Public Opinion', Symbolic Interaction 11(2): 161-74.Garcia, Luciano Miguel (2006) Έ1 Publico: La Triple Contingencia y el Curso del Relato', Revista Espahola de Sociologia 6: 91-104.Goffman, Erving ( 19%6)Frame Analysis: An Essay on the Organization of Experience. Boston: Northwestern University Press.Habermas, Jürgen (\979)Communication and the Evolution of Society. London: Heinemann.Habermas, Jürgen (1984/1987 [1981]) The Theory of Communicative Action, Vol. 1-2. London and Cambridge: Heinemann and Polity Press.Habermas, Jürgen (1996 [\992])Between Facts and Norms. Cambridge: Polity Press.Habermas, Jürgen {\999)Wahrheit und Rechtfertigung. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.Habermas, Jürgen (2003)7)•?///? and Justification. Cambridge: Polity Press.Habermas, Jürgen (2005)Zwischen Naturalismus und Religion. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.Habermas, Jürgen (2007) 'Kommunikative Rationalität und grenzüberschreitende Politik: eine Replik', in P. Niesen and B. Herborth(<dd$)Anarchie der kommunikativen Freiheit. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp, pp. 406-59.Haug, Christoph (2013) 'Organizing Spaces', Organization Studies 34(5-6): 705-32.Herborth, Benjamin and Kessler, Oliver (2009) 'Public Spheres', <s3.amazonaws. com/academia. edu.documents/29699277/IPS_public_sphere_April_2009.pdf>, accessed 10.10.2013.Jackendoff, Ray (1999) Languages of the Mind. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.Kant, Immanuel (1963) 'An Old Question Raised Again: Is the Human Race Constantly Progressing?', in Kant on Histoiy. Indianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill, pp. 137-54.Kaufmann, Laurence and Clément, Fabrice (2007) 'How Culture Comes to Mind: From Social Affordances to Cultural Analogies', Intellecta 46(2): 1-30.Kaufmann, Laurence and Cordonier, Laurent (2008) 'Vers un Naturalisme Social: À la Croisée des Sciences Sociales et des Sciences Cognitives, Reseaux 2/3 (No 148-9): 79-116.Krasnoff, Larry (1994) 'The Fact of Politics: History and Teleology in Kant', European Journal of Philosophy 2(1): 22-40.Leydesdorff, Loet (2007) The Knowledge-Based Economy. Boca Raton, Fl: Universal Publishers.Leydesdorff, Loet (2008) 'The Communication of Meaning and Knowledge in a Knowledge-Based Economy', Semiotix 13: 1-23.Leydesdorff, Loet (2009) 'Modelling "Triple Contingency'", in S. O'Tuama (ed.) Critical Turns in Critical Theory. London: Tauris Academic Studies, pp. 165-68.Luhmann, Niklas (1995 [1984]) Social Systems. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press.Lumsden, Charles J. and Wilson, Edward O. (1983) Promethean Fire: Reflections on the Origin of the Mind. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.Marx, Karl (1974) Grundrisse: Foundations of the Critique of Political Economy. Harmondsworth: Penguin.Miller, Max (1986) Kollektive Lernprozesse. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.Mithen, Steven (1998) The Prehistory of the Mind. London: Phoenix.Ocampo, Sergio P. and Zitello, Matias A. (2008) 'Estatutos Sociológicos del ConceptoComunicación en el Campo del Cultura', Latitude 2(1): 106-23.O'Mahony, Patrick and Delanty, Gerard (2002) Nationalism and Social Theory. London: Sage.O'Mahony, Patrick (2013) The Contemporaiy Theory of the Public Sphere. Oxford: Peter Lang.O'Tuama, Seamus ed. (2009) Critical Turns in Critical Theoiy. London: Tauris Academic Studies.Park, Robert E. (1936) 'Human Ecology', American Journal of Sociology 42(1): 1-15.Parsons, Talcott ( 1977) Social Systems and the Evolution of Action Theory. New York: Free Press.Piaget, Jean (1968) Moral Judgement of the Child. Harmonds worth: Penguin.Piaget, Jean (\973)Erkenntnistheorie der Wissenschaften vom Menschen: Hauptströmungen der sozialwissenschaftlichen Forschung. Frankfurt: Ullstein.Piaget, Jean (1983 [\910])Meine Theorie der geistigen Entwicklung. Frankfurt: Fischer.Russili, Chris (2004) 'Toward a Pragmatist Theory of Communication', PhD Thesis, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia.Simmel, Georg (1992 [1908]) Soziologie: Untersuchungen über der Formen der Vergesellschaftung, Gesamtausgabe Vol. 11. Frankfurt: Suhrkamp.Strydom, Piet (1996)'The Cognitive Order of Modernity: The "Scaffolding of Modernity" or the Rights Frame?' Unpublished manuscript, University College Cork, Ireland.Strydom, Piet (1999) 'Triple Contingency: The Theoretical Problem of the Public in Communication Societies', Philosophy and Social Criticism 25(2): 1-25.Strydom, Piet (2000)Discourse and Know/edge: The Making of Enlightenment Sociology. Liverpool: Liverpool University Press.Strydom, Piet (2001) 'The Problem of Triple Contingency in Habermas', Sociological Theory 19(2): 165-86.Strydom, Piet (2002)Risk, Environment and Society. Buckingham/Philadelphia: Open University Press.Strydom, Piet (2006)'Contemporary European Cognitive Social Theory', in G. Delanty (ed.) Handbook of Contemporary European Social Theory. London: Routledge, pp. 218-29.Strydom, Piet (2007) 'Introduction: A Cartography of Contemporary Cognitive Sociology', Special Issue on 'Social Theory after the Cognitive Revolution: Types of Contemporary Cognitive Sociology', European Journal of Social Theoty 10(3):339-356.Strydom, Piet (201\)Contemporary Critical Theory and Methodology. London: Routledge.Strydom, Piet (2012a)'Modernity and Cosmopolitanism: From a Critical Social Theory Perspective', in G. Delanty (ed.) Routledge Handbook of Cosmopolitan Studies. London: Routledge, pp. 25-37.Strydom, Piet (2012b) 'Toward a Global Cosmopolis? On the Formation of a Cosmopolitan Cultural Model', Irish Journal of Sociology 20(2): 28-50.Strydom, Piet (2013) 'The Counterfactual Imagination Punctuated by Triple Contingency: On Klaus Eder's Theory of the New Public Sphere', in A. Salvatore, Ο. Schmidtke and Η.-J. Trenz (eds) Rethinking the Public Sphere through Transnationalizing Processes. Basingstoke: Palgrave, pp. 56-74.Strydom, Piet (in press a) 'On the Cognitive Order of Society: Radicalising the Ontological Turn in Critical Theory', Pragmatics & Cognition.Strydom, Piet (in press b) 'The Latent Cognitive Sociology in Habermas: Extrapolated through a Commentary on Between Facts and Norms', Philosophy and Social Criticism.Trenz, Hans-Jörg and Eder, Klaus (2004) 'The Democratizing Dynamics of a European Public Sphere', European Journal of Social Theory 7(1): 5-25.
